From what I can tell from the preview "New Girl", I would have to say that the show seems pretty interesting because it's characters seem to delineate from usual stereotypes. Yesterday was the first time I had heard of the show, and after reading all these articles and watching the the preview, I am confident in saying that I do not think that "New Girl" is offensive or demeaning to women. I understand where the argument can be made. In the article "Is New Girl Secretly Feminist?", Zooey Deschanel is viewed in a negative light because she is seen as someone immature and dependent on male figures to teach her the way. Other critics of Zooey point out that she is merely another character learning the ropes to becoming the ideal woman by adhering to societal believes on what she should do and what she can't do.
Before "New Girl", my only experience with Zooey Deschanel is in her role in "500 Days of Summer." As other articles have pointed out, a perfect epitome of a "hipster" or "indie" pixie girl. I really don't see a problem with Zooey repeating her role as someone who is seen as different, because at least it's a deviation from the romantic comedy castes that we see so often. I just read a pretty interesting article talking about romantic comedies. It's written by a Chloe Angyal, editor of a blog called Feministing, working on a doctoral thesis on romantic comedies. The ironic thing is that when she was writing this article Chloe was going through her own breakup with her perfect boyfriend who had apparently dumped her the day before Valentines. She found herself acting like the characters on romantic comedies:
"You might think you're above the influence of these movies, that you're too savvy and cynical for your expectations and ideas to be shaped by them. I certainly thought I was, and maybe you are - but you're probably not. Romantic comedies shape the beliefs and expectations of even the most cynical and media-savvy among us, especially when they catch us at our most vulnerable."
After reading this article, I first must applaud her for putting together a rather in-depth analysis of romantic comedies, but more importantly I think Chloe has evoked the question of "How much of what we watch, is what we come to expect?"